Scalped tickets surface at Yonsei-Korea games; student sting draws criticism
In short
Scalped tickets appeared at this year's Yon-Ko games between Yonsei and Korea universities, held Oct. 2–3, and Korea University's student athletics bureau ran a sting operation on Sept. 29–30 that recovered 20 tickets from 18 people, Yonhap reported. Ten of the tickets were redistributed to students through an additional lottery. The operation drew criticism on campus over the sting method and the collection and partial disclosure of students' personal information, and students also questioned the organisers over about 200 seats reassigned to faculty.
Read the full story 2 min read
Scalped tickets for this year's Yon-Ko games between Yonsei and Korea universities appeared despite stricter rules on ticket resale that took effect in August, and students moved to recover tickets that had been resold, Chosun Ilbo reported. Yonhap reported that student self-governing bodies took on the enforcement themselves. [ 1 , 2 ]
According to Yonhap, which cited Korea University's student council and athletics bureau, the bureau that organised this year's games on Oct. 2–3 ran a crackdown on Sept. 29–30. Students posed as buyers, approached sellers and then identified themselves at the meeting point and took back the tickets, a tactic Yonhap described as a sting. Twenty tickets were recovered from 18 people — 15 ice hockey tickets and five rugby or football tickets. Ten that could be reassigned before the games were given to students through an additional lottery. [ 2 ]
The annual exchange series draws more demand for seats than it can meet from current students, alumni and staff, Yonhap reported. Tickets have been distributed free by lottery, but resale has been a recurring problem each year. A Korea University official said ticket management belongs to the area of student self-governance, while the school has worked with the student council and athletics bureau to prevent scalping and establish orderly attendance. [ 2 ]
Criticism of the operation surfaced on campus. A post on the Korea University board of the student-life platform Everytime on Sept. 30, titled a review of the legality of the athletics bureau's ticket-recovery process, drew more than 100 likes and reached the board's popular list, Yonhap reported. The post argued that the sting method, the collection of names and student numbers from those caught, and the disclosure of part of that information — surnames and admission years — exceeded the student body's authority. Students also raised doubts about the organisers' transparency, including an allegation that the bureau handed tickets arbitrarily to family and friends, and criticised them for concentrating on the crackdown while failing to address faculty seat allocations, Yonhap reported. [ 2 ]
According to the student council, the school notified it on Oct. 1, the day before the games opened, that 562 of the baseball seats would be set aside for faculty, and about 200 seats already assigned to students were switched to faculty seating, so about 200 students who had been allocated seats could not attend. The council said it had not agreed to the school's action but decided against a hard confrontation because a dispute risked confusion on the day and greater harm to students, and that its decision was aimed at protecting as many students' tickets as possible under the circumstances. [ 2 ]
Why it matters
The case tests how the tightened rules on ticket resale for performances and sports events are being applied in practice, and here enforcement was carried out by a student self-governing body rather than the school or police. That choice has turned a ticket-management matter into a campus dispute over the authority of student bodies and the handling of personal data. The documents do not say whether any authority is investigating or whether anyone has been penalised.
Key facts
- This year's Yon-Ko games between Yonsei and Korea universities were held Oct. 2–3 and were hosted by Korea University [ 1 , 2 ]
- Chosun Ilbo reported that scalped tickets appeared at the games even after revised rules in the Performance Act and the National Sports Promotion Act took effect in August, strengthening enforcement and penalties for ticket resale [ 1 ]
- Korea University's athletics bureau, which organised the games, ran a crackdown on scalping on Sept. 29–30 using students who posed as buyers [ 2 ]
- Twenty tickets were recovered from 18 people — 15 ice hockey tickets and five rugby or football tickets — and 10 that could be reissued before the games were given to students through an additional lottery, according to Yonhap [ 2 ]
- A post on the Everytime Korea University board on Sept. 30 questioning the legality of the ticket-recovery process drew more than 100 likes, Yonhap reported [ 2 ]
- The school told the student council on Oct. 1, the day before the games opened, that 562 baseball seats would be allocated to faculty, and about 200 seats already assigned to students were switched, leaving about 200 students without seats [ 2 ]
Confirmed by several sources
- Scalped tickets appeared at this year's Yon-Ko games between Yonsei and Korea universities, and students moved to recover tickets that had been resold [ 1 , 2 ]
- Korea University's athletics bureau ran a scalping crackdown on Sept. 29–30 and recovered 20 tickets from 18 people, including 15 ice hockey tickets and five rugby or football tickets, Yonhap reported [ 2 ]
- Ten recovered tickets that could be reassigned before the games were distributed to students through an additional lottery [ 2 ]
- A Korea University official said ticket management falls within student self-governance but that the school has cooperated with the student council and athletics bureau to prevent scalping and maintain orderly attendance, according to Yonhap [ 2 ]
- Criticism of the crackdown emerged on campus over the sting method and over the collection and partial disclosure of students' personal information [ 2 ]
Still unclear
- Whether the sting operation and the collection and partial disclosure of students' names, student numbers, surnames and admission years were unlawful The documents describe students' claim that the student body exceeded its authority, but cite no ruling, investigation or finding by any authority.
- An allegation raised on campus that the athletics bureau gave tickets arbitrarily to family members and friends Yonhap describes this as an on-campus suspicion and gives no supporting evidence or response from the organisers.
- Whether anyone was penalised or charged under the strengthened anti-scalping rules The documents describe the revised laws and the recovery of tickets but say nothing about penalties or legal proceedings.
- Why about 200 baseball seats already assigned to students were switched to faculty seats, and whether affected students received any compensation Only the student council's account of the notification and its consequences appears in the documents; the school's reasoning is not given.
What local media are saying
Timeline, local time
- Chosun Ilbo publishes its report that scalped tickets appeared at this year's Yon-Ko games and that students moved to recover tickets sold on the black market. [ 1 ]
- Yonhap reports that Korea University's athletics bureau ran the scalping crackdown on Sept. 29–30, recovering 20 tickets from 18 people, and that a Sept. 30 post on the Everytime Korea University board drew more than 100 likes. [ 2 ]