Survey: 41% of Korean nurses faced rights violations; 76% took no action
In short
A Korean Nurses Association survey of 2,105 nurses at medical institutions found 41.0% experienced human rights violations in the past year, most often verbal abuse, according to Newsis and Yonhap. Of those affected, 76.4% took no action, and 83.8% of that group said they expected no change even if they reported. The association presented the findings at a policy debate at the National Assembly Members' Office Building and called for more nursing staff and stronger protection systems.
Read the full story 2 min read
More than four in ten nurses working at medical institutions in South Korea say they experienced human rights violations in the past year, but most of those affected did not respond, according to a survey by the Korean Nurses Association. The association's nursing labor reform committee surveyed 2,105 nurses, and 41.0% reported experiencing violations, Newsis and Yonhap reported, with Seoul Shinmun carrying the same headline figures. Newsis said the results were presented at a policy debate on preventing rights violations against nurses and improving their working environment, held at the National Assembly Members' Office Building. [ 1 , 2 , 3 ]
Verbal abuse was the most commonly reported form of violation at 88.9%, followed by workplace bullying at 67.1%, sexual violence at 17.7% and physical violence at 17.0%, according to the two articles. Of the nurses who experienced violations, 76.4% took no action. The most cited reason, given by 83.8%, was a belief that reporting would bring no change; 36.7% cited fear of disadvantage in promotion or organizational life, 27.5% fear of retaliation by the perpetrator and 14.4% not knowing how to report. [ 1 , 2 ]
Among those who did respond, the reported outcomes were limited. Yonhap reported that 68.1% said their institution showed no change after they responded, while 12.7% reported separation from the perpetrator, 7.4% an official measure, and 2.5% said the problem was resolved or the situation improved. Newsis said the figures show that laws and systems banning rights violations are not matched by systems that protect victims and resolve problems at the hospital level. Asked to rank the most urgent improvements, 80.7% of respondents named increasing the number of nurses, followed by stronger legal protection at 47.6%, improvement of organizational culture and eradication of “taeum” at 41.9%, stronger violence prevention measures at 39.2% and stronger institutional protection systems at 31.4%, Newsis reported. [ 1 , 2 ]
Based on the findings, the nurses association proposed policy tasks including nursing staffing standards that reflect institution type and patient severity, protection of victims and prevention of retaliation after a report, a response system linking investigation, recurrence prevention and follow-up management, expansion of the dedicated nurse educator system, guaranteed training periods for new nurses, and regular surveys with standardized indicators. Association president Shin Kyung-rim said illegal and unjust rights violations and wrong practices in the field should no longer be passed down, calling for the nursing community's own reform efforts alongside institutional work to create a working environment where nurses' safety is guaranteed, Yonhap reported. Newsis noted that cases of nurses dying after complaining of workplace bullying known as “taeum” have recurred every year. Yonhap attributed the findings to the association with a reference to 7 October, while Newsis said the results were presented that day, 6 October. [ 1 , 2 ]
Why it matters
The results indicate that existing laws and rules against workplace abuse are not translating into protection at the hospital level, since most victims neither report nor see institutional change afterward. The nurses association is using the data to press for staffing standards, victim protection and follow-up systems, and respondents themselves ranked more nursing staff as the most urgent measure.
Key facts
- A survey of 2,105 nurses working at medical institutions found 41.0% had experienced human rights violations in the past year. [ 1 , 2 , 3 ]
- Among those who experienced violations, 88.9% cited verbal abuse, 67.1% workplace bullying, 17.7% sexual violence and 17.0% physical violence. [ 1 , 2 ]
- 76.4% of nurses who experienced violations took no action of any kind. [ 1 , 2 , 3 ]
- The most common reason for not responding was the belief that reporting would change nothing, cited by 83.8%. [ 1 , 2 ]
- Of those who did respond, 68.1% said nothing changed at their institution, while 2.5% said the problem was resolved or the situation improved. [ 1 , 2 ]
- 80.7% of respondents named increasing nursing staff as the most urgent improvement, followed by stronger legal protection at 47.6%. [ 1 , 2 ]
- The Korean Nurses Association proposed staffing standards by institution type and patient severity, victim protection and anti-retaliation measures, and a system linking investigation, recurrence prevention and follow-up. [ 2 ]
- The results were presented at a policy debate on preventing rights violations and improving working conditions for nurses at medical institutions, held at the National Assembly Members' Office Building. [ 1 ]
Confirmed by several sources
- The survey covered 2,105 nurses at medical institutions and was conducted by the Korean Nurses Association's nursing labor reform committee. [ 1 , 2 ]
- 41.0% of respondents said they experienced human rights violations in the past year. [ 1 , 2 , 3 ]
- About 76% of those who experienced violations did not respond. [ 1 , 2 , 3 ]
- Verbal abuse was the most common form of violation reported. [ 1 , 2 ]
Still unclear
- The exact date the survey results were released and the debate was held. Yonhap, published on the evening of 6 October, attributes the results to the Korean Nurses Association with a “7日” reference, while Newsis says the results were presented that day at a forum at the National Assembly Members' Office Building; the documents do not reconcile the two dates.
- The survey period, sampling method and margin of error. Neither Newsis nor Yonhap states how or when the 2,105 nurses were surveyed.
- Whether the proposed policy measures will be taken up by the government or legislature. The documents report the association's proposals and mention lawmakers attending the forum, but no legislative or government commitment is stated.
- The full content of Seoul Shinmun's report. Only the outlet's headline is available, so any detail beyond the headline figures is single-sourced to Newsis and Yonhap.
What local media are saying
Timeline, local time
- Newsis publishes the survey findings, reporting that the results were presented that day at a policy debate at the National Assembly Members' Office Building. [ 1 ]
- Yonhap publishes its report on the survey, including the association's policy proposals and its president's comments. [ 2 ]
- Seoul Shinmun publishes a report headlined on four in ten nurses experiencing rights violations and 76% of victims not responding. [ 3 ]