Tennessee Republicans weigh new execution methods after botched lethal injection
In short
Some of Tennessee's top Republicans said they want to explore alternative ways of executing condemned prisoners after the failed execution of Christa Pike on Sept. 30, in which a large dose of pentobarbital did not kill her. Gov. Bill Lee has halted all further executions in the state and announced an independent investigation, and the head of the state prison system will step down, CBS News reported. Pike, now 50, remains hospitalized under guard, unconscious and on a ventilator with blisters and burns on her arms, her lawyers have said.
Read the full story 2 min read
Some of Tennessee's top Republicans said Monday they want to explore alternative ways of executing condemned prisoners after the failed execution of Christa Pike, which relied on a large dose of pentobarbital, the Associated Press and The Seattle Times reported. [ 3 , 4 ]
U.S. Sen. Marsha Blackburn, the state's Republican candidate for governor, said Pike's unsuccessful execution last week “should not be grounds to halt carrying out the death penalty.” Tennessee instead needs to reevaluate the way it does executions, she said. “If it's lethal injection, if it is electric chair, what we do know is we have to find a way to do this — and do it successfully,” Blackburn told the AP. [ 3 , 4 ]
House Speaker Cameron Sexton said legislative leaders have already spoken with Blackburn about potential changes to state execution laws during their 2027 session. “We want to broaden it, include more methods,” Sexton said. “What those are as of today, I'm not sure. But I don't think there's any method that's off the table at this point.” [ 3 , 4 ]
Pike, now 50, was sentenced to death over the 1995 murder of Colleen Slemmer, whose photographs were displayed outside Riverbend Maximum Security Institution before the planned execution, according to the AP. She was scheduled to be executed on Sept. 30, 2026, in Nashville. [ 3 , 4 ]
Prison officials gave Pike two doses of a barbiturate that were supposed to be lethal but did not ultimately kill her, the AP and The Seattle Times reported. Emergency vehicles arrived at Riverbend after the execution was halted. Pike has remained hospitalized under guard, left unconscious and on a ventilator with blisters and burns on her arms from the drug, her lawyers have said. CBS News reported that Gov. Bill Lee halted all further executions in the state, announced an independent investigation to be conducted by a former U.S. attorney, and that the head of Tennessee's prison system will step down. [ 1 , 2 , 3 , 4 ]
Most U.S. states that allow executions use lethal injection as their primary means, though South Carolina sets its default as electrocution and Idaho the firing squad, according to the Death Penalty Information Center, as cited by the AP. Death by electricity or gas is authorized in nine states, including five that specify nitrogen gas, and five states authorize a firing squad. Florida, which leads the nation in executions this year, uses a three-drug lethal injection that includes a sedative, a paralytic and a drug that stops the heart. [ 3 , 4 ]
Sexton said he does not yet know which additional methods Tennessee might adopt, and the documents give no detail on the scope or timing of the independent investigation. [ 1 , 3 , 4 ]
Why it matters
Tennessee has paused executions while an independent investigation proceeds, and its Republican leaders are discussing changes to state execution law for the 2027 session, which would affect how the state carries out death sentences. The failed procedure also feeds a national argument over execution methods; the documents note that most U.S. states that allow executions use lethal injection, while others authorize electrocution, gas or a firing squad.
Key facts
- Prison officials gave Christa Pike two doses of a barbiturate that were supposed to be lethal during her Sept. 30 execution, but the execution was halted and she was not killed. [ 3 , 4 ]
- Pike, now 50, remains hospitalized under guard, unconscious and on a ventilator with blisters and burns on her arms from the drug, her lawyers have said. [ 3 , 4 ]
- Gov. Bill Lee halted all further executions in Tennessee and announced an independent investigation to be conducted by a former U.S. attorney. [ 1 , 2 ]
- The head of Tennessee's prison system will step down, CBS News reported. [ 1 ]
- U.S. Sen. Marsha Blackburn, the state's Republican candidate for governor, said the failed execution “should not be grounds to halt carrying out the death penalty” and that Tennessee needs to reevaluate how it does executions. [ 3 , 4 ]
- House Speaker Cameron Sexton said lawmakers want to broaden the methods available, and top legislative leaders have already spoken with Blackburn about changing state execution laws during their 2027 session. [ 3 , 4 ]
- Nine states authorize death by electricity or gas, including five that specify nitrogen gas, and five states authorize a firing squad, according to the Death Penalty Information Center. [ 3 , 4 ]
Confirmed by several sources
- Christa Pike's Sept. 30 execution was halted after doses of pentobarbital failed to kill her, and she was not executed. [ 1 , 2 , 3 , 4 ]
- Top Tennessee Republicans, including U.S. Sen. Marsha Blackburn and House Speaker Cameron Sexton, want to explore alternative execution methods. [ 3 , 4 ]
- Legislative leaders have discussed changes to state execution laws for their 2027 session. [ 3 , 4 ]
- Tennessee's execution procedures used a large dose of pentobarbital, and Pike's planned execution drew a protest against the death penalty at the Tennessee State Capitol. [ 3 , 4 ]
Still unclear
- The departure of the head of Tennessee's prison system, including the official's name and the timing of the exit. Only CBS News reports the resignation, and no name or date is given.
- Pike's current medical condition. The description of her condition comes from her lawyers, as reported by the AP and The Seattle Times; no official medical or prison statement is cited.
- Which alternative execution methods Tennessee would adopt. House Speaker Cameron Sexton said he is not sure what those methods are as of Monday, and no method has been formally proposed.
- The scope and timeline of the independent investigation announced by Gov. Bill Lee. CBS News reports the investigation will be led by a former U.S. attorney but gives no further detail.
- Tennessee Gov. Bill Lee halted all further executions in the state. Reported by a single source so far
What local media are saying
Timeline, local time
- CBS News reports that the head of Tennessee's prison system will step down after the botched execution of Christa Pike, and that Gov. Bill Lee announced an independent investigation by a former U.S. attorney. [ 1 ]
- CBS News reports that Gov. Bill Lee has halted all further executions in the state following Pike's botched procedure. [ 2 ]
- The Associated Press reports that some of Tennessee's top Republicans want to explore alternative execution methods, citing Sen. Marsha Blackburn and House Speaker Cameron Sexton. [ 3 ]
- The Seattle Times publishes the same AP reporting on Republican interest in additional execution methods. [ 4 ]