China, Philippines trade blame over aircraft encounter near Scarborough Shoal
In short
Chinese and Philippine military aircraft came into close proximity over Scarborough Shoal in the South China Sea, and both sides accused the other of dangerous behaviour. China’s Southern Theater Command said a Philippine C-208 patrol aircraft entered the airspace without Chinese approval on Oct 3 and was warned and expelled; the Philippine military said one Chinese J-16 repeatedly closed in on its plane, which returned without incident.
Read the full story 2 min read
Chinese and Philippine military aircraft flew close to each other over Scarborough Shoal in the South China Sea, and both sides accused the other’s forces of acting dangerously. China’s Southern Theater Command spokesperson Jia Shichen said in a statement issued a day before the reports that a Philippine C-208 patrol aircraft entered the airspace over Huangyan Dao — the Chinese name for the shoal — on Oct 3 without Chinese government approval, and that sea and air forces tracked, monitored, warned and expelled it. Newsis reported in its headline that China sent J-16 fighters carrying live missiles and that the Philippine aircraft was expelled. [ 1 , 2 ]
The Philippine military disclosed the incident on Oct 4, saying a C-208 on a routine maritime patrol near Scarborough Shoal met two Chinese military aircraft. It said one of the Chinese J-16s repeatedly came close and manoeuvred in front of and around its aircraft, which it said put aviation safety at risk, and it criticised what it called repeated unsafe and coercive actions against Philippine government vessels and aircraft carrying out legitimate operations. The patrol aircraft completed its mission and returned without incident, the Philippine military said, according to Yonhap. [ 1 ]
The two accounts differ on the outcome. China said the Philippine aircraft was warned off and expelled, a description echoed in the Newsis headline, while the Philippine military said the plane carried out its patrol and returned normally. Yonhap reported that China’s statement called Huangyan Dao “China’s inherent territory”, described the Philippine flight as a serious infringement of Chinese sovereignty that carried a high risk of causing an accidental incident at sea or in the air, and urged Manila to stop what it called provocations. [ 1 , 2 ]
Scarborough Shoal lies about 220 km west of the Philippine island of Luzon and is claimed by both countries. China bases its claim on the so-called nine-dash line, while the Philippines bases its rights on an exclusive economic zone under the UN Convention on the Law of the Sea. In 2016 the Permanent Court of Arbitration in The Hague ruled that China’s nine-dash line claim had no legal basis; China does not accept the ruling. [ 1 ]
Why it matters
The encounter adds to friction between Chinese and Philippine forces around a feature both countries claim, and both sides’ own statements point to the risk of an unintended incident at sea or in the air. The Philippine military said unsafe and coercive actions against its government vessels and aircraft have been repeated, a formulation that keeps regional tension high.
Key facts
- China’s Southern Theater Command said a Philippine C-208 patrol aircraft entered the airspace over Huangyan Dao, its name for Scarborough Shoal, without Chinese government approval on Oct 3. [ 1 ]
- China’s military said it deployed sea and air forces to track, monitor, warn and expel the Philippine aircraft. [ 1 , 2 ]
- The Philippine military said a Chinese J-16 fighter repeatedly approached and manoeuvred in front of and around its patrol aircraft near Scarborough Shoal. [ 1 ]
- The Philippine military said the patrol aircraft completed its mission and returned without incident, while China said the aircraft was expelled. [ 1 , 2 ]
- Newsis reported in its headline that the Chinese J-16s carried live missiles; the Yonhap report did not mention weapons. [ 1 , 2 ]
- Scarborough Shoal lies about 220 km west of the Philippine island of Luzon and is claimed by both China and the Philippines. [ 1 ]
- China bases its claim on the nine-dash line and the Philippines on an exclusive economic zone under UNCLOS; a 2016 arbitration ruling rejected China’s claim, which China does not accept. [ 1 ]
Confirmed by several sources
- Chinese and Philippine military aircraft came into close proximity over Scarborough Shoal, with each side accusing the other of dangerous behaviour. [ 1 , 2 ]
- China’s military said a Philippine C-208 patrol aircraft entered the airspace over Scarborough Shoal without Chinese approval on Oct 3 and was tracked, warned and expelled. [ 1 , 2 ]
- The Philippine military said its patrol aircraft completed its mission and returned without incident. [ 1 ]
- The Philippine military said Chinese aircraft flew dangerously close to its plane near Scarborough Shoal. [ 1 ]
Still unclear
- Whether the Philippine aircraft was in fact forced away from the area. China says the aircraft was warned and expelled, while the Philippine military says it finished its routine patrol and returned normally; the documents give no independent verification of either account.
- Whether the Chinese J-16 fighters involved carried live missiles. Only the Newsis headline mentions live missiles; the Yonhap report on the same incident does not mention armament.
- What Newsis reported beyond its headline. The article text available under the Newsis headline deals with an unrelated domestic story, so only the headline could be used for this event.
What local media are saying
Timeline, local time
- A Philippine C-208 patrol aircraft entered airspace over Huangyan Dao, or Scarborough Shoal, without Chinese government approval, according to China’s Southern Theater Command. [ 1 ]
- The Philippine military publicly disclosed the incident and criticised dangerous close flying by Chinese military aircraft. [ 1 ]
- Chinese Southern Theater Command spokesperson Jia Shichen issued a statement saying the Philippine aircraft was tracked, warned and expelled. [ 1 ]
- Yonhap published its report on the encounter and the conflicting accounts. [ 1 ]
- Newsis published a headline saying China sent J-16s armed with live missiles and the Philippine aircraft was expelled. [ 2 ]