Japan PM Takaichi: political support must not sway budget allocation
In short
Prime Minister Takaichi Sanae told the House of Representatives on Oct 7 that bringing political support or non-support into budget allocation is only natural, and said she would ensure appropriate allocation is thoroughly carried out. She was answering Komeito’s Okamoto Mitsunari about remarks by Agriculture Minister Yana Kazuo that he cut road budgets for municipalities whose mayors did not back him in February’s lower house election. Yana has denied seeking cuts and the land ministry says no lobbying from him was confirmed, while TBS reported the prime minister intends to keep him in his post.
Read the full story 2 min read
Prime Minister Takaichi Sanae said in the House of Representatives plenary on Oct 7 that bringing political support or non-support into budget allocation is only natural, and that she would again ensure appropriate budget allocation is thoroughly carried out. She was answering a question from Komeito representative Okamoto Mitsunari about remarks by Agriculture Minister Yana Kazuo on road budget cuts. [ 2 , 3 , 4 , 5 , 6 ]
Takaichi said road budget allocation from the national government to local authorities is made by comprehensively taking into account requests from local governments, the progress of projects and whether an area is a priority allocation target. She said the municipalities in question were allocated budgets on that basis, and Mainichi reported she denied arbitrary allocation by Yana. [ 3 , 4 , 5 , 6 ]
The question followed Yana’s remark that he cut road budgets for municipalities whose mayors did not support him in February’s lower house election; Asahi and Sankei said the municipalities were two in his home prefecture of Tochigi. Sankei reported that Yana had retracted the remark and apologised, while TBS reported Yana saying he had never sought any reduction and that it had been confirmed there was no lobbying from him to the land ministry. Sankei also reported the ministry saying no lobbying from Yana to cut the budgets had been confirmed. [ 4 , 6 , 7 , 8 ]
Okamoto said the budget is not politicians’ money but tax entrusted by the people, and asked for the specific reasons for the reduction and for the principle that political support and non-support must not enter budget allocation to be enforced within the government. Mainichi reported this was the first time the prime minister had directly addressed the Yana issue. [ 3 , 4 , 6 ]
Asahi noted in its article that the government and ruling parties had recently moved to increase the Okinawa development budget by more than 300 billion yen after a governor backed by the LDP and others won, a point not carried by the other documents. [ 4 ]
In the afternoon question session, TBS reported that debate also covered a consumption tax cut on food. TBS later reported that the prime minister intends to keep Yana in his post, and that there is no sign of the issue being settled. [ 7 , 8 ]
Why it matters
The exchange puts the government’s spending decisions, and the principle that budgets should not be used for political reward, under parliamentary scrutiny, with the opposition asking that the principle be enforced across the government. Sankei reported the minister had already retracted the remark and apologised, but the issue remains unsettled, and TBS reported the prime minister intends to keep him in his post.
Key facts
- Prime Minister Takaichi Sanae said in the Oct 7 lower house plenary that bringing political support or non-support into budget allocation is only natural. [ 2 , 3 , 4 , 5 , 6 ]
- She said she would again ensure appropriate budget allocation is thoroughly carried out. [ 2 , 5 , 6 ]
- She was answering a question from Komeito representative Okamoto Mitsunari. [ 3 , 4 , 5 , 6 ]
- The question concerned Agriculture Minister Yana Kazuo’s remark that road budgets were cut for municipalities whose mayors did not support him in the February lower house election. [ 4 , 6 ]
- Takaichi said road budget allocation comprehensively considers local government requests, project progress and priority allocation targets, and that the Tochigi municipalities in question were allocated on that basis. [ 4 , 5 , 6 ]
- Yana denied seeking a reduction, and the land ministry said no lobbying from him was confirmed. [ 6 , 7 ]
- Sankei reported that Yana had retracted the remark and apologised. [ 6 ]
- TBS reported the prime minister intends to keep Yana in his post and that the issue shows no sign of being settled. [ 8 ]
Confirmed by several sources
- Prime Minister Takaichi said in the Oct 7 House of Representatives plenary that political support or non-support should not be brought into budget allocation, and that she would again ensure appropriate allocation. [ 2 , 3 , 4 , 5 , 6 ]
- The remark was made in reply to a question from Komeito representative Okamoto Mitsunari. [ 3 , 4 , 5 , 6 ]
- Takaichi said road budget allocation takes comprehensive account of local government requests, project progress and priority allocation targets, and that the municipalities in question were allocated on that basis. [ 4 , 5 , 6 ]
- Agriculture Minister Yana denied seeking a reduction in the road budgets, and the land ministry said no lobbying from him was confirmed. [ 6 , 7 ]
Still unclear
- Whether Agriculture Minister Yana retracted his remark and apologised, as Sankei reported. Only Sankei reports the retraction and apology; the other documents describe the remark without mentioning a retraction.
- Whether the road budgets of the two Tochigi municipalities were in fact reduced, and for what specific reason. Okamoto asked for the specific reasons and the prime minister said allocation followed the usual comprehensive considerations, but no document states the specific reason or confirms a reduction.
- Whether Prime Minister Takaichi will keep Yana in his post and whether the issue will be settled. Only TBS reports the intention to keep him and says there is no sign of the matter being resolved.
- Asahi’s observation that the government and ruling parties moved to raise the Okinawa development budget by more than 300 billion yen after a governor backed by the LDP and others won. This appears in one outlet’s article as a reported contrast and is not confirmed by the other documents.
What local media are saying
Timeline, local time
- Jiji Press reports the prime minister saying she will thoroughly ensure appropriate budget allocation. [ 1 ]
- TBS reports Takaichi’s remark in the House of Representatives plenary, answering Komeito’s Okamoto Mitsunari about Agriculture Minister Yana’s budget-cut remark. [ 2 ]
- Mainichi reports it is the first time the prime minister has directly addressed the Yana issue. [ 3 ]
- Asahi reports the question concerned road budgets for two municipalities in Yana’s home prefecture of Tochigi. [ 4 ]
- Nikkei reports Takaichi’s pledge and her explanation of how road budgets are allocated. [ 5 ]
- Sankei reports that Yana had retracted the remark and apologised, and that the land ministry said no lobbying from him was confirmed. [ 6 ]
- TBS reports the afternoon question session also covered a consumption tax cut on food. [ 7 ]
- TBS reports the prime minister intends to keep Yana in his post and that the issue shows no sign of being settled. [ 8 ]