EU holds closed talks on response to possible large-scale hybrid attack, Politico reports
In short
The EU has intensified closed-door consultations on preparing for possible large-scale hybrid attacks that could cause significant civilian casualties, Politico reported, citing EU diplomats and officials. Talks among ambassadors of the 27 member states have run for several weeks and intensified after a drone with explosives was found at Leipzig airport in August, according to Kommersant's account. Some member states criticize the initiatives, saying Brussels is overstepping its security role and duplicating NATO functions.
Read the full story 2 min read
The European Union has intensified closed-door consultations on preparing for possible large-scale hybrid attacks that could cause significant civilian casualties, Politico reported, citing EU diplomats and officials. TASS, RBC and Kommersant all carried accounts of the report. Kommersant, citing Politico, said ambassadors of all 27 member states have held secret meetings over the past several weeks. [ 1 , 2 , 3 ]
The discussions intensified after a drone carrying explosives was found at Leipzig airport in August, according to the accounts. Kommersant reported that German Interior Minister Alexander Dobrindt described that incident as a hybrid attack by Russia; TASS referred to it only as the drone incident at Leipzig airport. [ 1 , 3 ]
According to Kommersant's account of the report, diplomats are discussing scenarios including the deployment of emergency response teams, financial assistance to an affected state and coordination of communications by the leaders of EU institutions. EU Justice Commissioner Michael McGrath told Politico that the bloc is strengthening its ability to forecast and identify threats, improving early warning systems and ensuring rapid collective response, Kommersant reported. [ 3 ]
Some member states criticize the initiatives, arguing that Brussels is going beyond its security role and duplicating NATO functions, RBC and Kommersant reported. Kommersant quoted former NATO spokesperson Oana Lungescu as saying: “If confusion arises…, this can slow decision-making, which has consequences.” [ 2 , 3 ]
For threats that do not reach the level of armed aggression, the EU envisages a separate mechanism for joint response, designed along lines close to NATO's Article 4 consultation procedure: it would coordinate actions among states without itself meaning military intervention, Kommersant reported. If a situation is classified as armed aggression, Article 42.7 of the EU treaty applies, obliging states to help the affected country but providing no automatic military response; each government determines the form of help for itself, so a collective decision does not override national policy, the report said. [ 3 ]
Why it matters
If the EU builds a joint response mechanism for threats below the level of armed aggression, it would sit alongside NATO's existing consultation procedures, and the reported disputes over duplication could slow decisions in a crisis. The documents also indicate the limits of the bloc's tools: aid obligations under Article 42.7 carry no automatic military response, leaving the form of help to each government.
Key facts
- The EU has intensified closed-door consultations on preparing for possible large-scale hybrid attacks that could cause significant civilian casualties, Politico reported, citing EU diplomats and officials. [ 1 , 2 , 3 ]
- Ambassadors of all 27 EU member states have held secret meetings over the past several weeks, according to Kommersant's account of the Politico report. [ 3 ]
- The talks intensified after a drone with explosives was found at Leipzig airport in August, an incident German Interior Minister Alexander Dobrindt called a hybrid attack by Russia, Kommersant reported. [ 3 ]
- Diplomats discussed scenarios including deploying emergency response teams, providing financial aid to an affected state and coordinating communications by EU institution leaders. [ 3 ]
- EU Justice Commissioner Michael McGrath told Politico the bloc is strengthening threat forecasting and identification, improving early warning systems and building capacity for rapid collective response. [ 3 ]
- Some member states criticize the initiatives, saying Brussels goes beyond its security role and duplicates NATO functions, RBC and Kommersant reported. [ 2 , 3 ]
- For threats below the level of armed aggression the EU envisages a separate joint response mechanism close to NATO's Article 4 consultations, while armed aggression would trigger Article 42.7, which requires help but no automatic military response. [ 3 ]
Confirmed by several sources
- The EU is preparing for a possible large-scale hybrid attack that could cause casualties, as reported by Politico citing diplomats and EU officials. [ 1 , 2 , 3 ]
- The discussions intensified after a drone incident at Leipzig airport in August. [ 1 , 3 ]
- There are disagreements within the EU over the preparations, including whether the bloc is duplicating NATO functions. [ 2 , 3 ]
Still unclear
- Which member states are criticizing the EU initiatives and how many of them object. The documents say “some” states take that position and name no countries.
- Whether the Leipzig drone incident is officially established as a Russian hybrid attack. Only Kommersant attributes that characterization, to German Interior Minister Alexander Dobrindt; the other documents refer to “the drone incident” without attribution.
- The exact content and timing of the EU's planned joint response mechanism. Kommersant describes it only in general terms, as close to NATO's Article 4 consultation procedure.
- Whether the secret ambassadorial meetings are still under way. Kommersant says only that they have taken place over the past several weeks, without giving dates.
What local media are saying
Timeline, local time
- A drone with explosives is found at Leipzig airport, the incident cited as the trigger for intensified EU discussions. [ 1 , 3 ]
- TASS reports that the EU is preparing for a possible “nightmare” hybrid attack from outside. [ 1 ]
- RBC reports disputes inside the EU during preparation for a large-scale hybrid attack scenario, including over duplicating NATO functions. [ 2 ]
- Kommersant publishes details of the EU's response scenarios, mechanisms and criticism from member states. [ 3 ]